Yes, it is one and the same church and school. The school has been torn down and the church has been de-churched or whatever you call it. I think it might become a community center. It was on the corner of Pacific and Sackman Streets.
Did you graduate from OLL or go to the school.
Ariola's made my wedding cake years ago and I still cannot find ANY cake or pastry that is as good. Since then I moved from NY and sorry to say you can only get the original cakes and pastry in NY. Ariola's is the best!!!!